Rebuilding Trust Across the Divide Isn’t Just Possible—It’s Essential

There is much to applaud in the range of efforts to facilitate civil dialogue and build empathy. However, we’ve taken a different approach, one that puts action ahead of words.

Two years ago, the Rural Urban Bridge Initiative, which I cofounded with Erica Etelson, launched Community Works, or “CWorks,” in four rural, deeply red counties in Virginia. One year later, we initiated it in rural Georgia.

Our process was simple. We identified county Democratic committees that were struggling but interested in trying something different. We then worked with them to undertake regular, concrete, nonpolitical community work, side by side with civic groups, churches, veterans and senior citizen groups, local nonprofits, and, eventually, local elected officials. Local CWorks chapters, each affiliated with the county Democratic committee, do at least three community events per month, turning out dozens (or more) volunteers to solve local problems collaboratively with their neighbors.

Our goal? To test the idea that, if people worked side by side to address local needs, bit by bit, trust would be rebuilt. Democrats and liberals, working with independents and conservatives to pack food for the needy, pick up trash in the creek, fix a neighbor’s roof, install smoke alarms in trailers, and organize activities for kids. And much more. No proselytizing, no persuasion, no candidate buttons.

We’re barely two years in, but it is clearly working. The six CWorks chapters in Virginia and Georgia have held more than 500 local events, involving at least 200 collaborations with a wide range of civic and community organizations. According to CWorks national director, Meredith Dean, “Stuff is getting done, community is being rekindled, and people are feeling hope. We’ve also seen very positive impacts on the local Democratic committees themselves, many of which were previously discouraged. With the addition of CWorks, they’ve experienced a dramatic growth in energy, enthusiasm, and volunteers.”

Collaborative community problem solving efforts like Community Works are generating interest from people in many places. CWorks itself is rapidly expanding, with new chapters recently added in Minnesota, Alabama, Maryland, California, and elsewhere. For many on the left, particularly young people, there’s a hunger to do something concrete and constructive, rather than just fighting the bad stuff that never seems to stop. Could collective local action, done collaboratively and intentionally with folks “on the other side” save us from Donald Trump? We don’t know the answer just yet. But it is clear that when we stop trying to convince people that they’re wrong and start working together to fix things, we build trust.

Trust is a prerequisite to persuasion. It can also, we have found, be a generator of enthusiasm and activism.

Kenya Adams’s involvement with the Jenkins County, Georgia CW chapter helped her “become much more aware of the needs in our area. Many young adults are in a state of “IDK, IDC”[I Don’t Know, I Don’t Care], totally disengaged. But working with CWorks motivated me to join my local Democratic Committee and become president of our first-ever Young Dems chapter.”

We’ve seen how nonpolitical work leads people to political involvement. Shanelle Carr, also in Georgia, describes herself as “one of those people who sat on the couch and complained.” But after experiencing the power of local community work, “everything changed for me. I started attending our School Board and Town Council meetings.” Community Works, she said, “set a fire in me to become more engaged and active in my community.”

This strategy is helping revitalize local Democratic committees in rural, red areas. But is it helping overcome the overwhelmingly negative views of Democrats? Anecdotally, at least, the evidence for this is strong and growing. Heather Vaughn who leads the CWorks chapter for the Scott County, Virginia Democrats says that their events increasingly are “in response to other groups or individuals asking us for assistance. At this point, people know who we, they know they can count on us and they trust us to help.”

In a county where fewer than 20 percent of people voted for the Democratic ticket in 2024, that’s significant.

The Page County Democrats CWorks chapter has been among the most active and successful thus far. With their dazzling track record of getting things done, the community—again, overwhelmingly red—has come to see them in a very different light, extending even to the Republican-controlled county Board of Supervisors. They’ve moved from skepticism of this Democratic initiative to now actively working to support and partner with the CWorks chapter.

As one of the Page County volunteers, Bob Richey put it, “Community Works is bridging a political divide that I didn’t think was bridgeable.”