When you’re truly stumped on what to give your boss, says Williams, go with a surefire crowd-pleaser: something that can be consumed. “Even if it’s not perfect, it’s going to be eaten or drunk, and then it will be a nice memory as opposed to something that sits on a shelf,” she reasons. Fisher suggests a small-batch item in pretty packaging, like Brightland’s cold-pressed olive oil Duo: the more bold Awake, ideal for roasting, and the smooth, perfect-for-salads Alive. Made with preservative-free ingredients sourced from family-owned Californian farms, “the quality is top-notch,” she says. “I use Awake whenever I host a dinner party because it has a bolder flavor than other olive oils; it’s great for dipping bread.”